Optimising Asset Tracking Solution Designs

Asset tracking is a key business process that enables businesses to keep tabs on their valuable physical and human resources, whether they are in a single location or moving within the supply chain. An effective asset-tracking system enhances the efficiency of the business and helps improve profitability by minimising inventory loss and identifying obsolete assets. Asset tracking can also apply to valuable human resources, e.g., in a healthcare environment, where scarce expertise can be quickly located when urgently required.

The rapid growth of the IoT has driven the emergence of a range of innovative technologies which are increasingly being adopted in asset-tracking systems. With such a wide spectrum of options, it can sometimes be difficult to choose the optimum combination for a given application. This article describes the main technologies currently available to support asset-tracking solutions and discusses how to choose the optimal technology for a specific application.

As a leading global technology distributor and solutions provider, Avnet Silica has the product portfolio and solutions expertise to ensure that their customers optimise the design of their asset-tracking solutions. This article concludes with an examination of selected technologies within the extensive Avnet Silica portfolio.

Factors to Consider When Designing an Asset Tracking Solution

An asset tracking system comprises a device attached to the asset which can determine and broadcast its location along with status information, and a system which can receive and interpret the data. Beyond this high-level description, the requirements of a specific asset tracking system will be determined by a range of factors based on the use case, including:

  • Global/locational area for tracking
  • Level of accuracy needed for location data
  • Location update rates
  • Access to power
  • Dimensions that need to be tracked
  • Number of assets to be tracked
  • Asset values
  • The physical environments the assets will be in
  • Ease of deployment/ease of use
  • Budgetary limitations
  • Wireless technologies are key to both positioning and connectivity within asset tracking solutions, and the current leading technologies are described below along with their suitability for different use cases.

 

Overview of Asset Tracking Technologies

Asset tracking technologies can be broadly segmented into long-range tracking technologies or short-range – also known as Real-Time Positioning Systems (RTLS).

A long-range tracking application, such as a refrigerated shipping container, would need a solution capable of tracking it from the originating warehouse to the final destination, figure 1, while reporting on parameters such as its internal temperature.

 

Long range asset tracking solution

Figure 1 - Elements of a typical long-range asset-tracking solution

Cargo ship aerial shot - Asset Tracking

Looking for support with your next Asset-Tracking project?

Avnet Silica and its leading suppliers are supporting a number of businesses across EMEA to revolutionise their asset tracking systems and procedures, making their business smarter, more profitable and giving them an advantage over their competition.

Tools

Design Hub

Browse and review over a thousand proven reference designs to accelerate your design process. Try our design tool and then export it to your CAD tool of choice.

Main body cont and conclusion (LC)

Display portlet menu

Of all long-range positioning technologies, the Global Navigation Satellite System (GNSS), which includes the original GPS constellation as well as the GLONASS, GALILEO, and BEIDOU systems, provides the most ubiquitous global coverage. A GNSS tracker communicates with the satellite network using a process known as trilateration, where at least three satellites are used to determine the latitude, longitude, elevation, and time of the trackable asset. Regional and local positioning can also be achieved using cellular and LPWAN networks, where base stations act as beacons. While not as precise as GNSS positioning, cellular tracking leverages the ubiquity, standards, and service availability of commercial networks. Solutions using cellular positioning consume less battery power than those based on GNSS. Cellular tracking is often used for fleet management applications and can be used in combination with GNSS tracking or on a standalone basis.

 

Long-range tracking systems require a wide area network for internet connectivity, and multiple wireless technologies may be needed, depending on the container's location. Satellite networks, such as Iridium or Inmarsat, would be essential at sea, while less expensive cellular or LP-WAN networks could be used when closer to shore or on the road between the warehouse and port.

Short-range tracking or Real-Time Location Systems (RTLS) solutions, figure 2, are typically deployed to address indoor use cases, such as the tracking of people and equipment. Short-range solutions are common in large buildings like hospitals or factories, although they can also be used outdoors, in yards, and so on.

GNSS positioning is not viable in indoor locations, so alternative wireless ranging techniques must be used. Internet connectivity in these environments can be achieved using existing infrastructure, such as Wi-Fi.

Short range asset tracking solution

Figure 2 - A typical short-range asset-tracking solution

RTLS typically use wireless tags attached to the asset or persons being tracked, along with a system of fixed anchor points covering the tracking zone. Positioning is determined in several ways: Two Way Ranging (TWR) calculates the distance between the tags and anchors, while Time Difference of Arrival (TDoA) positioning is based on the difference in arrival time of the signals at the anchors. Angle of Arrival (AOA) can be used when the propagation angle of the signal is measurable, and Received Signal Strength (RSS) can be used to estimate the distance between the tag and anchor. Sophisticated algorithms calculate positioning based on data from the anchors, and each method differs in required processing power and transmitted signals.

The demand for accurate and reliable indoor positioning solutions for asset tracking has led to the development of numerous standards and technologies, including RFID, ultra-wideband (UWB), Wi-Fi sniffing, and BLE, each suited to a subset of use cases and applications.

Figure 3 below provides a comparison of the various technologies available for both long- and short-range positioning solutions.

  Accuracy Scalability Range Data Transfer Rates Summary
RFID Varies widely; accurate to last scan only Highly scalable Up to 600 m n/a Effective for object detection but not true localisation
UWB ~1m - 10cm Highly scalable Up to 100m Up to 27 Mbps Effective for localised, precise asset tracking
BLE ~2m - ~3m Limited Up to 100m Up to 2 Mbps Effective for localised, zone-based tracking
Wi-Fi ~3m Very limited Up to 50m Up to 1 Gbps Effective for zone-based tracking at small scale
LPWAN ~40m - 800m Highly scalable Up to several km Variable Many effective tracking options depending on region
Cellular ~ 30m - 100m Scalable outdoors ~30km  100 Mbps + Effective for tracking large/high-value assets outdoors
GPS ~7 - 10m  Scalable outdoors Global access within line-of-sight of satellite n/a Effective for tracking large assets outdoors

 

Examples of Long and Short-Range Asset Tracking Technologies

 

Nordic nRF5

Figure 3 - The nRF5 Series of SoC modules

As illustrated above, a wide range of technologies have evolved to support asset tracking, leveraging developments in the IoT such as miniaturisation, advanced wireless communications, and power management. Developers of asset tracking solutions must choose carefully, not only to ensure that the selected products meet the needs of the specific application but also that the supplier ecosystem can provide the necessary development tools and support.

The nRF series of SoC modules from Nordic Semiconductor, for example, as shown in figure 4, address the requirements of various short-range location methods.

Based on powerful Arm Cortex processors, these extremely low-power modules integrate devices from Nordic’s rich partner ecosystem to offer a range of wireless technologies. The nRF5 series, for instance, combines BLE direction-finding capability with common wireless protocols including Mesh, Thread, and Zigbee. These modules are suitable for deployment across the RTLS solution, in asset tags, anchor devices, gateways, and backend servers. Nordic is also collaborating with their partner, Qorvo, to combine their nRF5 technology with Qorvo’s UWB transceiver to jointly offer a UWB positioning solution. Nordic’s portfolio also includes modules to support cellular and LPWAN positioning and products for power optimisation and tracking software algorithms.

For long-range tracking systems, miromico’s portfolio of tracking products includes a range of tracker devices, gateways, and sensor modules, ideally suited to cargo tracking and other long-range use cases. The powerful and flexible miro Trackit tracker device, as shown in figure 5, supports GNSS positioning as well as Wi-Fi sniffing and BLE positioning, enabling its use both indoors and outdoors. The device also supports the LoRa LPWAN protocol for WAN connectivity and is available with a range of sensors.

 

Choosing the best technology for a specific asset tracking solution involves understanding the needs of the application and finding products that are not only fit for purpose but are also backed by comprehensive development tools and support environments.

With many years of experience in hardware components and in-depth knowledge of IoT solutions, Avnet Silica and its world-leading supplier partnerships are ideally placed to support our customers' in-house teams with the knowledge and tools to accelerate the development of advanced asset-tracking solutions.

The sample products featured represent a subset of Avnet Silica’s comprehensive portfolio. To discuss the specific needs of your application, contact us today.

miromico TrakIt device

Figure 4 - The TrackIt device from miromico

Featured Suppliers

Supplier

Nordic Semiconductor

Nordic Semiconductor is a Norwegian fabless semiconductor company specializing in wireless communication technology that powers the Internet of Things (IoT). Nordic was established in 1983 and has more than 1300 employees across the globe.

Supplier

Miromico

As an IoT hardware provider, Miromico supplies its customers state-of-the-art LoRaWAN® communication modules as well as ready-to-use LPWAN sensors and gateways that are at the leading edge of technology.

Supplier

Qorvo

Qorvo supplies innovative semiconductor solutions that make a better world possible. They combine product and technology leadership, systems-level expertise and global manufacturing scale to quickly solve customers' most complex challenges.